This podcast appears to be over 90 minutes long so I’m just going to give live reactions and be done with it. I have no life but even I can’t spend more time than that on this podcast. So let’s get to it!
—-
Wow. Barely into the pod and the gaslighting has begun with Eli’s "We're going to make this quick."
We’re kicking off the podcast with manufactured conspiracies? What is this? Infowars? And now Andy is suggesting killing dogs to solve this “issue”.
I’m going to pause the pod for a second so I can add that I was wildly impressed by the poems that were delivered at the draft and instead of regaling in the creativity of this friend group, we’re talking about some bullshit with the moon pies and fake ass cappuccinos? (Or CAPpuccinos as the kids might say.) The moon pies were arguably the worst whammy of the entire event. I guess because our hosts’ poems were amongst the bottom of the barrel they don’t want to talk about it. But I say Great job, League! OK, back to the pod.
They are still talking about moon pies. This is is not a promising start to this season of the podcast. Are we hearing the podcast jump the shark? Mercifully, I just heard someone say "Gotta keep it moving."
Side note: I will eat Moon Pies again before I ever eat at Battista’s. Maybe the worst meal I’ve ever had in Vegas.
Why would you ever add Watson into the mix? Watson has pretty much proven to be an utter disaster at predicting fantasy football success. I do wonder which has been worse - Watson or whatever Yahoo uses to predict the best draft. There is no worse curse than winning the Yahoo Best Draft award.
On the bright side, Andy’s “system” might be the most effort he’s ever put into the podcast outside of the first few alien updates.
Thanks to Andy for nipping Eli's rosterbating over his own team in the bud. When someone starts talking about RJ Harvey, you know that it’s time to pull the plug.
I guess I spoke too soon about Andy bringing more effort this year. "Yep, this team is boring" is the searing insight that we've come to expect from Andy. You really get what you pay for with this podcast.
26 minutes in and we’re losing steam. Eli references Brandon Jacobs who hasn’t played in the NFL in over a decade.
One passing comment that I agree with is that I never get the references of Mark’s team names.
Andy’s silence on supporting End Racism is deafening. “Well… sure.” I feel like inviting four more honkies - including one with an aversion to chocolate - into the league has people feeling a little more comfortable exposing their prejudices. Did Eli expand the league to celebrate 20 years or to combat The Great Replacement?
Andy shows that he’s in midseason form with “I think DJ Metcalf is better than people give him credit for.”
“Yeah, yeah, I don’t know” will be the name of Andy’s memoir.
Travis Etienne announced that his last name is pronounce Achane but apparently this podcast doesn’t care or doesn’t know or doesn’t respect non-white people enough to get their names right. Etienne is probably too Cajun for this country club. How soon until Player #14 is back on the podcast? I thought the podcast was jumping the shark but now I think we’re seeing a heel turn.
Ashton Jeanty can be top 5?! Andy doesn’t like guys on bad teams but now is saying that someone who might miss week 1 and if/when he does get healthy, will be running behind KIRK COUSINS! and a terrible offense is potentially Top 5? Where’s the consistency?
Eli cites “Egbuka before injury” as evidence of a higher ceiling this year, which is odd since Egbuka is already injured again this year.
This has been a longstanding issue but, with the pod’s glaring turn towards the right wing, Eli’s insistence on using a hard R in One Shady Motha is troubling. And likely VERY telling.
Andy seems to be basing most of his insight on how people played last year although it’s been fairly well documented that fantasy success is not often repeatable.
Fun Fact: Christian McCaffrey hasn’t survived the season after getting 250+ carries the year prior and he got over 300 last season.
This podcast needs an intermission. Or a mercy killing.
I’d say this podcast could’ve been an email but it definitely would have gone to the spam folder so a podcast is a better way to make sure we all suffer through it.
“He doesn’t have a set it and forget it WR”, says the guy who is starting Brian Thomas Jr. and Quentin Johnston. I’m going to take this time to bring up something that will make this pod very enjoyable this season and that is the fact that nobody, and I mean NOBODY, is less emotionally equipped to deal with boom-or-bust players than Eli and his roster is stacked with them.
An hour and 8 minutes into the podcast, Andy utters “Let me think”, which would be the first for this podcast.
I’m going to bring up the downside of Johnny’s roster - Kenneth Walker can’t stay healthy, KC’s line is beat to shit, and Walker always bounces runs to the outside and both of the Chiefs’s tackles are hurt. Jadarian Price didn’t even handle a full workload in college, had very little in the way of receiving work, and didn’t muster a single carry in the preseason because he was already banged up a bit. I think there’s a real concern about those guys being in one piece at the end of the season and Price will likely lose carries to Charbonnet when the games start to matter. Hell, given how the Seahawks run things, I wouldn’t be surprised if George Holani got far more playing time than expected. Johnny’s TE position is a recovering George Kittle and the Jets’ backup TE, who was also dealing with an injury. Johnny might have a strongest receiving core in the league but my guess is that he’ll eventually need to make a trade to fill in some holes when the bumps and bruises of an NFL season start to wear on his lineup.
After suffering through an hour and a half of this alleged podcast, we now have the worst new segment ever farted in our face. Adding insult to injury, Eli won’t even own coming up with it, already blaming poor Dana for being the impetus of this abortion.
- Good lord, he’s reading the e-mail addresses?
- ”In case you don’t remember” This guy has zero clue who Eli is.
- This e-mail was definitely never read by anyone at corporate. Immediate delete.
- That might have been the most embarrassing Harvard name drop in the history of Harvard. Does Harvard have an editing class so we can get this podcast down to a reasonable length?
- What is this email? Oh my god, Costco lost 3200 dollars?
- Wait, you’ve been at Costco for all of these years and don’t know that executive members get in early? THAT is what set this all off? I’ve never had a Costco membership and even I know that!
- The worst part about that email is that Eli is going to rejoin Costco before 2027 is over.
- I’ve never turned off the podcast but I’m coming very close. What is this?!
- I might cancel my podcast subscription after that debacle.
I’ve never wanted to hear an AI generated outro more in my life.
Final Thought - That was a great draft we just had and it was disappointing that this podcast couldn’t live up to it. An hour and a half for Andy to say he doesn’t like guys on bad teams and for Eli to say that he likes the teams that drafted the guys he wanted to draft seems excessive. If Eli and Andy were NFL players, they’d be put on the Commissioner’s Exempt list for this assault on our ears. Do better, gentlemen!